In short: The PNG Auditor-General public accounts report for 2019 explained: the disclaimer, K674.3m cash gap, trust accounts, guarantees and practical next steps.
أبرز الخلاصات
The PNG Auditor-General public accounts report for 2019 ended in a disclaimer of opinion: the Auditor-General could not confirm the government’s cash, trust account, investment, debt and guarantee balances well enough to say whether the accounts were fair. The causes are mainly reconciliation and record-keeping gaps that build up over years, and they can be fixed with monthly routines, complete registers and better use of the IFMS.
- Cash does not agree with the bank. Statement A showed K1.11 billion while bank confirmations showed K1.79 billion, a net variance of K674.3 million.
- The main receiver account was not reconciled. the Receiver of Public Monies account had not been reconciled since 2015, and only 2 of 34 subsidiary reconciliations were provided.
- Trust accounts need a single register. the register listed 381 active accounts against 311 reported, and seven accounts were overdrawn by K29.83 million.
- Balance sheet items were unreliable. investments were overstated by K5.90 billion and K14.04 billion of guarantees could not be verified without a register.
- Financing partners point the same way. the IMF has asked for modernised cash management and stronger debt management, and Australia is supporting public accounts and IPSAS work.
مقدمة
In 2026 the Auditor-General’s Office of Papua New Guinea posted Part I of its Report on the Public Accounts for 2019 on its website. The report was signed at Waigani on 27 August 2024, and its central message is clear: the Auditor-General was unable to express an opinion on the 2019 Public Accounts. For a country working to repair its budget under IMF-supported programmes, that finding matters.
قد تبدو إخلاء المسؤولية مقلقة، ولكن يجب قراءتها بعناية. فهي لا تقول إن الأموال قد سرقت، بل تقول إن الأدلة والأنظمة الكامنة وراء الحسابات لم تكن قوية بالقدر الذي يسمح للمدقق بالوصول إلى استنتاج. وتلك مشكلة تتعلق بالمطابقة، والسجلات، والجداول الزمنية، وهي مشكلة تشترك فيها حكومات عديدة. ويعد نشر التقرير علانية خطوة إيجابية بحد ذاته للمساءلة، لأنه يمنح وزارة المالية، ووزارة الخزينة، والوكالات، والبرلمان قائمة مشتركة بما يجب إصلاحه.
This article explains what the report found, why the opinion was disclaimed, what the IMF and other partners are saying about public financial management in Papua New Guinea, and the practical steps that would move the accounts towards an audit opinion.
What the PNG Auditor-General Public Accounts Report Found
The Public Accounts are the government’s annual financial statements. They include Statement A on cash balances, Statement B on receipts, Statement C on trust accounts, and further statements on public debt, investments and guarantees. Several of these statements are produced from the Integrated Financial Management System (IFMS).
يسجل التقرير لعام 2019 إجمالي إيرادات قدره 26.37 مليار K و إجمالي نفقات قدره 26.4 مليار K. وفي مواجهة هذه المجاميع، حدد المراجع العام مشكلات فيเกือบทุก بيان يحمل رصيداً:
- a net K674.3 million difference between reported cash and bank confirmations
- a main Receiver of Public Monies account not reconciled since 2015
- 70 more active trust accounts in the register than in the published statement
- investments reported at K18.05 billion that the auditor considered should be K12.15 billion
- a K720.92 million difference between the public debt statement and the debt recording system
- K14.04 billion of guarantees that could not be verified
- weak payroll reconciliation in most of the 25 agencies audited
The report also noted that the 2019 Public Accounts reached the Auditor-General only in November 2022, almost three years after the year closed. Late accounts make every other problem harder, because evidence ages, staff move on and differences become more difficult to trace.
Why the Opinion Was Disclaimed Rather Than Qualified
Auditors choose between four kinds of opinion. An unmodified opinion says the accounts are fair. A qualified opinion says they are fair except for specific matters. An adverse opinion says they are materially wrong. A disclaimer is used when the auditor cannot obtain enough evidence to form any view, and the possible effects are both material and pervasive.
In the 2019 audit, the problems touched the starting point of all government accounting, cash. If the cash balance cannot be proved, receipts and payments cannot be confirmed either. When trust accounts, investments, debt and guarantees are added, the uncertainty runs through the whole set of statements. That is why the auditor could not limit the opinion to a few qualifications.
The good news is that disclaimers usually have a small number of root causes. Fix the cash reconciliation and the registers, and many other findings fall away.
The K674.3 Million Cash Gap and the Receiver of Public Monies Account
Statement A reported bank balances of K1.11 billion. Confirmations obtained directly from the banks showed K1.79 billion. The net variance was K674.3 million, and some individual account differences were much larger before netting. A government with more cash in the bank than in its books is not necessarily losing money, but it cannot show where that money came from, what it is committed to, or whether some payments were never recorded.
The Receiver of Public Monies account collects government revenue. The report found that the main account had not been reconciled since 2015, and that only two of its 34 subsidiary accounts had reconciliations available for audit. Once a reconciliation falls years behind, unexplained items pile up and staff tend to carry them forward rather than investigate.
The practical answer is to stop the gap growing first, then work backwards. That means reconciling the current month, every month, within a fixed deadline; agreeing with the Auditor-General a cut-off date and approach for older years; and reporting any residual unexplained amount transparently rather than leaving it hidden in suspense accounts.
Trust Accounts: Register, Overdrawn and Unsupported Balances
Trust accounts hold money set aside for specific purposes, often outside the normal appropriation cycle. They are useful, but they need firm control. The 2019 audit found that the reconciliation register listed 381 active trust accounts while Statement C reported 311. Seven trust accounts were overdrawn by a combined K29.83 million, and 41 accounts with balances totalling K48.9 million lacked evidence of existence and accuracy.
حساب الائتمان المكشوف يعني أن المدفوعات تمت بما يتجاوز الأموال المتاحة، وهو ما لا ينبغي أن يكون ممكنا إذا كانت الموافقة وضوابط النظام تعمل. أوصى المراجع العام، من بين خطوات أخرى، بإزالة حسابات الائتمان الملغاة من نظام معلومات الإدارة المالية (IFMS) حتى لا يمكن استخدامها. سجل واحد مملوك، ومطابقة شهرية لكل حساب مع البنك ودفتر الأستاذ، وحظر نظام على المدفوعات التي تتجاوز الرصيد من شأنه أن يعالج معظم هذه النتائج.
Investments, Public Debt and the Missing Guarantees Register
Statement F reported state investments at K18.05 billion. The Auditor-General concluded that they were overstated by K5.90 billion and should have been K12.15 billion. Overstatement of this kind usually arises when values are carried forward without being checked against the latest financial statements of the companies concerned.
On public debt, Statement G showed about K31.9 billion while the Commonwealth Secretariat Debt Recording and Management System showed about K31.1 billion, an unexplained difference of K720.92 million. Debt is the figure the IMF, rating agencies and investors watch most closely, so the two records need to agree every month.
The largest unverified figure was K14.04 billion of guarantees reported in Statement I. The report notes that the Department of Treasury does not maintain a register of guarantees and that a register has been recommended since 2008, with little progress. Guarantees are contingent liabilities: they cost nothing until they are called, and then they can cost a great deal. A register with the beneficiary, lender, amount, expiry and approval reference for each guarantee is the basic tool for managing that risk.
Payroll, Agency Controls and Timeliness
بلغت مخصصات الموظفين 5.31 مليار kina في عام 2019، أي حوالي 19% من إجمالي الإنفاق. يذكر التقرير أن معظم الوكالات الـ 25 التي تم تدقيقها لم تقم بمطابقة كشوف المرتبات. ووجدت عمليات التدقيق للوكالات أيضاً سجلات عروض مفقودة، ومدفوعات تمت على فواتير شكلية، وسلفاً تمت تسويتها بشكل ضعيف، وسجلات أصول مفقودة.
Two recommendations deal with the reporting framework itself. Recommendation 1 asks the Department of Finance to issue a financial instruction requiring compliance with International Public Sector Accounting Standards; the department responded that the Public Accounts would be prepared on the IPSAS cash basis from 2023. Recommendation 2 asks for the Public Finances (Management) Act to be amended so that the accounts are submitted for audit by 31 March of the following year, allowing audit and reporting to be completed by 30 June.
ما تقوله مراجعات صندوق النقد الدولي وشركاء التمويل
Papua New Guinea has been implementing reforms under IMF Extended Credit Facility and Extended Fund Facility arrangements, with a Resilience and Sustainability Facility. When the IMF Executive Board completed the fifth reviews in December 2025, releasing SDR121.07 million (about US$165 million) under the ECF and EFF and SDR39.48 million (about US$54 million) under the RSF, it advised the authorities to strengthen debt management capacity and modernise cash management. The related staff report, published as IMF Country Report No. 2026/129, stresses sustained revenue reform, prudent spending and more efficient public investment to reduce debt vulnerabilities.
Islands Business reported in April 2026 that a staff-level agreement had been reached on the sixth reviews and that the fiscal deficit had narrowed to 2.4% of GDP in 2025, with a balanced budget targeted for 2027. Reliable cash and debt reporting is what makes such targets credible.
Other partners are active too. The World Bank approved US$150 million in budget support in December 2025, including PNG’s first US$50 million Catastrophe Deferred Drawdown Option, backing tax and state-owned enterprise dividend reforms. Australia, through the Australia–PNG Economic Partnership, has procured a review of Department of Finance PFM systems needs against gaps in the IFMS, and has supported advisory work on producing and quality-assuring the Public Accounts and moving from cash-based reporting towards full IPSAS.
| Finding in the 2019 report | Figure | الإصلاح العملي الأول |
|---|---|---|
| تأكيدات النقد مقابل البنك | تباين صافي قدره K674.3m | Monthly bank reconciliation with a fixed deadline and sign-off |
| Receiver of Public Monies | Not reconciled since 2015; 2 of 34 subsidiaries | Current-month reconciliation first, agreed catch-up plan for old years |
| Trust accounts | 381 vs 311; 7 overdrawn by K29.83m | Single owned register; IFMS block on overdrawing; close revoked accounts |
| Investments | مبالغ فيها بمقدار 5.90 مليار K | Annual revaluation from company accounts |
| Public debt | K720.92m difference | Monthly ledger to debt system reconciliation |
| الضمانات | 14.04 مليار كينيا غير مؤكد | Guarantee register owned by Treasury |
Practical Steps for Finance, Treasury and Agencies
Moving from a disclaimer to a qualified, and later unmodified, opinion is a multi-year task. A realistic sequence would look like this:
- Department of Finance: reconcile all central bank accounts monthly within ten working days, starting with the Receiver of Public Monies account and its subsidiaries; agree with the Auditor-General how far back to reconcile.
- دائرة المالية: إنشاء سجل واحد لحسابات الأمانة، ومطابقته مع الكشف (C) والبنك، وإغلاق الحسابات الملغاة في نظام الإدارة المالية المتكامل (IFMS) وتكوين النظام لوقف المدفوعات التي تتجاوز الأرصدة المتاحة.
- Department of Treasury: create a guarantee register, reconcile the debt statement to the debt recording system each month, and assign a named owner for each difference.
- Finance and Treasury together: revalue state investments from the latest company financial statements and correct prior-period errors with clear disclosure.
- الجهات: مطابقة كشوف المرتبات مع دفتر الأستاذ والبنك شهرياً، والاحتفاظ بسجلات عروض الأسعار والأصول، وتصفية السلف قبل إصدار سلف جديدة.
- All: set a year-end closing timetable that delivers the accounts to the Auditor-General by 31 March, and track every audit recommendation in a public action plan.
Treasury single account principles can support these steps. Fewer bank accounts mean fewer reconciliations, less idle cash and a clearer picture for cash forecasting, which is the kind of cash management modernisation the IMF has asked for.
أسئلة جوهرية ينبغي أن يطرحها قادة الحكومات والمشاريع
Do we know our true cash position at the end of each month?
إذا كانت الإجابة تعتمد على تسوية متأخرة بشهور، فلا. التسوية الشهرية لكل حساب مركزي هي الأولوية الأولى.
Who owns each trust account, and who would notice if it were overdrawn?
Each account needs a named owner, a purpose, a monthly reconciliation and a system control that blocks overdrawing.
Can we list every guarantee the state has issued?
بدون سجل، لا تستطيع الحكومة قياس أو الإفصاح عن التزام طارئ يحتمل أن يكون كبيراً. يُعد بناء السجل خطوة منخفضة التكلفة وعالية القيمة.
هل تتطابق أرقام الديون في حساباتنا مع تلك الموجودة في نظام الديون لدينا؟
يجب أن تتطابق كل شهر. وينبغي تفسير أي فرق، وتخصيصه، وتسويته قبل نهاية العام.
Are we using the IFMS controls we already have?
يمكن لحقوق الوصول، وسير عمل الموافقات، وتقارير الاستثناءات، وإغلاق الحسابات في نظام إدارة المالية الحكومية منع العديد من الأخطاء إذا تم تفعيلها ومراجعتها.
Is our action plan on audit findings public and tracked?
الخطة المنشورة التي توضح المسؤولين والتواريخ تبني الثقة مع البرلمان وشركاء التمويل وتُظهر التقدم المُحرز بين عمليات التدقيق.
كيف يمكن لـ Risalat أن تساعد
تتعاون شركة رسالة مع وزارات المالية والخزينة مكاتب التدقيق لتعزيز الحسابات العامة. يعمل تدريب الحسابات العامة ومطابقة حسابات الائتمان في سنغافورة على مطابقة البنوك والمستقبلين، ومراقبة حسابات الائتمان، وسجلات الضمان والديون، وضوابط نظام الإدارة المالية الحكومية (IFMS) والاستجابة لإخلاء المسؤولية، باستخدام نتائج بابوا غينيا الجديدة كحالة دراسية. يمكن للمؤسسات البدء بـ تشخيص تدقيق الحوكمة المجاني لمعرفة وضع أنظمتهم الخاصة.
الأسئلة الشائعة
What opinion did the PNG Auditor-General give on the 2019 Public Accounts?
A disclaimer of opinion. The Auditor-General was unable to obtain enough evidence on cash, trust accounts, investments, debt and guarantees to express an opinion. The report was signed on 27 August 2024.
What is the K674.3 million variance?
إنه الفرق الصافي بين رصيد النقد المبلغ عنه في البيان أ (1.11 مليار K) والأرصدة المؤكدة من قبل البنوك (1.79 مليار K) لعام 2019.
Does a disclaimer mean money is missing?
Not necessarily. It means the records and reconciliations were not strong enough for the auditor to reach a conclusion. The fixes are mainly reconciliation, registers and timely reporting.
What has the IMF said about cash management in PNG?
On completing the fifth reviews in December 2025, the IMF advised strengthening debt management capacity and modernising cash management.
المصادر
- Auditor-General of PNG: Report on the Public Accounts 2019, Part I
- IMF PR 25/422: IMF completes fifth reviews for Papua New Guinea
- IMF Country Report No. 2026/129 (RePEc listing)
- Islands Business: IMF greenlights US$216 million for PNG (April 2026)
- البنك الدولي يدعم إصلاحات بابوا غينيا الجديدة لتعزيز الإيرادات (ديسمبر 2025)
- DFAT AusConnect: evaluation of Department of Finance PFM systems needs (APEP)
- APEP Government Public Accounting & Financial Reporting Adviser (DoF)
- PNG Department of Finance: Integrated Financial Management System
شاهد
Know people who should read this? Become an Ambassador or write with Risalat.
شركاء في نجاح المشاريع منذ 2011، نقدم التشخيص والدعم الاستشاري والتعلم التطبيقي للوزارات والهيئات العامة وفرق المشاريع.
هل تحتاج إلى مساعدة في تطبيق ذلك عملياً؟
ابدأ بتشخيص مجاني مدته 10 دقائق أو تحدث إلى خبرائنا.

