Ideas clave
- Understanding the issue and its evidence. People often need a journey rather than a particular vehicle.
- Design choices and technical delivery. A platform can show routes, prices and disruptions, but true integration requires consistent data and commercial agreements.
- Financing, procurement and governance. A convenient bundle is not automatically affordable.
- Implementation, safeguards and measurement. Providers may enter and exit markets quickly, leaving passengers without promised options.
- Application to public agencies and donor-funded projects. Track door-to-door time, missed connections, fare burden, accessibility, public-transport ridership and private-car kilometres.
In short: A practical guide to mobility as a service, with evidence, implementation choices, risks and lessons for ministries, public agencies and donor-funded.
Free self-check: the digital readiness assessment gives how ready your institution is for digital services, data and AI, in about 10 minutes.
In short: Mobility as a Service, or MaaS, combines information and sometimes booking and payment for public transport, shared vehicles and other travel options through a coordinated interface. It is useful when it makes sustainable journeys easier, not simply when a city launches an app.
El Foro Internacional del Transporte ha examinado cómo MaaS debe integrarse con el transporte público y cómo los reguladores pueden proteger la competencia, los derechos de datos y los objetivos de servicio público.
Esta guía actualizada revisa el artículo original de Risalat y separa los conceptos consolidados de las afirmaciones que requieren nueva evidencia. Está dirigida a profesionales que deben decidir qué financiar, contratar, regular o medir. Los escenarios ilustrativos que siguen son ejemplos didácticos, no informes de proyectos ya concluidos.
The earlier article also highlighted a continuing consideration: MaaS can successfully be operated in those cities where different transport modes are available. As public transport is still at the heart of MaaS, a city must have adequate public transport services to replace the alternate need of the user to own a car. The practical implication is to test this proposition against current local evidence before applying it as policy.
The earlier article also highlighted a continuing consideration: Implementing and Operating a MaaS service requires a single identity for a user, open data, and open payment methods from different transport modes. Many transport operators are unwilling or even legally prohibited to allow third-party ticket sales. In such tight legal frameworks implementing MaaS would not be feasible. The practical implication is to test this proposition against current local evidence before applying it as policy.
The earlier article also highlighted a continuing consideration: Regardless of how exciting and appealing the applications of MaaS might sound, there are several confrontations to its implementation. We discuss some of them below:. The practical implication is to test this proposition against current local evidence before applying it as policy.
El artículo anterior también destacó una consideración continua: Los desafíos de la urbanización han abierto múltiples puertas a tecnologías innovadoras que se considera darán forma al futuro de la movilidad urbana. El coche y la bicicleta compartidos, el transporte a la demanda y los viajes compartidos son cada vez más comunes en las áreas urbanas de todo el mundo. Estos servicios de movilidad basados en aplicaciones están impulsados por el cambio en la mentalidad de los clientes. La implicación práctica es probar esta propuesta frente a la evidencia local actual antes de aplicarla como política.
Comprender la cuestión y su evidencia
From ownership to access
People often need a journey rather than a particular vehicle. A shared bicycle, bus, metro and short walk may together meet that need, provided transfers are reliable and the combined price is understandable.
Antes de establecer una meta de la propiedad al acceso, el equipo responsable debe definir la población o el activo cubierto, la condición actual y la fuente de su información de referencia. Una línea de base útil registra tanto lo que se conoce como lo que sigue siendo incierto. En una evaluación de proyectos, esto evita que una narrativa plausible se confunda con evidencia de demanda o impacto.
The role of public transport
MaaS cannot compensate for absent or unreliable core services. Frequent, accessible buses and trains should form the backbone, with shared services filling specific first-mile, last-mile or off-peak gaps.
The practical test for the role of public transport is whether two independent reviewers would reach a similar conclusion using the same records. Specify the definition of success, the relevant technical standard and the point at which a design needs reconsideration. Document exceptions openly rather than averaging away difficult cases.
Opciones de diseño y ejecución técnica
Journey planning and integrated payment
A platform can show routes, prices and disruptions, but true integration requires consistent data and commercial agreements. Ticketing rules, refunds and customer support become especially important when several operators are involved.
Consider a hypothetical pilot focused on journey planning and integrated payment. The implementation team should begin with a narrowly defined use case, test it under ordinary operating conditions and record user experience alongside technical performance. Procurement should permit correction of design defects before large-scale roll-out.
Governance and interoperability
Transport authorities should define open interfaces, minimum service standards and access to essential information. Contracts should prevent one intermediary from hiding competitors or using public data to undermine public objectives.
Operational readiness for governance and interoperability includes trained staff, a maintenance budget, reliable data and a route for complaints. If one of these is missing, the project may meet its construction or installation milestone while failing to deliver the intended service. Acceptance criteria should therefore include observed performance, not just equipment delivery.
Financiación, contratación y gobernanza
Pricing and incentives
A convenient bundle is not automatically affordable. Authorities can test caps, concessions, transfer discounts and incentives for low-emission modes while checking whether subscriptions exclude occasional users.
For pricing and incentives, a business case should distinguish initial investment from recurring costs. Compare alternatives on a common time horizon, including training, replacement, supervision and the cost of service interruptions. The cheapest compliant tender may not provide the lowest whole-life cost.
Privacy and data stewardship
Location histories can reveal work, health and personal routines. Operators should minimise identifiable data, publish retention rules and make service access possible without unnecessary tracking.
Governance of privacy and data stewardship should clarify who approves changes, who holds the supplier accountable and who pays when assumptions prove wrong. A decision log helps explain trade-offs to auditors and affected communities. Material changes should be reflected in the budget, schedule and risk register before approval.
Control de la decisión: ¿Ha comparado el equipo una línea de base sin intervención, un piloto limitado y una intervención a escala con los mismos criterios de coste, riesgo y resultados? Registre los supuestos de cada opción y el motivo por el que se eligió una de ellas.
Implementación, salvaguardas y medición
Commercial and service risks
Providers may enter and exit markets quickly, leaving passengers without promised options. Continuity plans, performance bonds where appropriate and interoperable customer records reduce dependence on a single supplier.
A practical control for commercial and service risks is to assign an owner, a reporting interval and an action threshold. Monitoring is useful only when findings lead to a decision: investigate, correct, redesign or stop. The threshold should be established before the data are reviewed to reduce pressure to declare success.
Cómo probar un programa piloto
Choose a corridor with measurable problems, document baseline travel time and mode share, then trial integrated information or payment. Compare outcomes with a similar corridor where feasible.
Evaluation of how to test a pilot should look for unintended effects as well as intended benefits. Record who gains access, who bears costs and whether outcomes differ across locations or user groups. When attribution is uncertain, describe the limitations instead of presenting a correlation as proof of impact.
Ejercicio práctico: Entregue a un equipo multifuncional la línea de base, el presupuesto y dos diseños alternativos. Pídale que prepare una nota de decisión de una página que identifique la principal incertidumbre, tres riesgos de implementación, la evidencia necesaria para la aprobación y el detonante de las medidas correctivas.
Aplicación en organismos públicos y proyectos financiados por donantes
Indicators that matter
Rastree el tiempo de puerta a puerta, las conexiones perdidas, la carga de tarifas, la accesibilidad, el uso del transporte público y los kilómetros de automóviles privados. Las descargas de aplicaciones por sí solas no pueden demostrar la reducción de la congestión o las emisiones.
A ministry or project implementation unit addressing indicators that matter can start with a short diagnostic: map mandates, list approvals, identify missing skills and test whether the proposed intervention fits existing operating arrangements. The result should be a prioritised workplan with named owners, deadlines and verifiable deliverables.
Public agencies and financed projects
Los municipios y los proyectos de movilidad urbana financiados por donantes deben coordinar a los operadores, las autoridades de competencia, los organismos de protección de datos y los grupos de pasajeros antes de licitar una plataforma. Las decisiones de inversión deben seguir los resultados del transporte, no la marca del software.
In donor-financed work, public agencies and financed projects should be reflected in procurement specifications, financial planning, stakeholder engagement and reporting where relevant. The financing agreement and applicable national law determine the actual obligations. Teams should verify those instruments rather than assume a single donor procedure applies everywhere.
Primeros 30 días: Verifique la línea de base y consulte a los usuarios u operadores afectados. Examine las cuatro primeras cuestiones de esta guía a la luz de los datos locales disponibles. Elabore una lista breve de lagunas de evidencia y de decisiones que no pueden aplazarse sin riesgo.
Días 31 a 60: Pruebe una intervención viable, perfeccione la especificación técnica y confirme la financiación para todo el ciclo de vida. Acuerde las responsabilidades entre los titulares de las políticas, los organismos ejecutores, los proveedores y los órganos de supervisión. Publique un registro de riesgos y un plan de seguimiento que puedan mantenerse con la capacidad existente.
Días 61 a 90: Revise los primeros resultados con los usuarios y con especialistas independientes, corrija los supuestos débiles y decida si ampliar, rediseñar o interrumpir la intervención. Conserve las lecciones aprendidas en las plantillas de contratación y en los procedimientos operativos para que el siguiente proyecto no repita errores evitables.
For a field review of commercial and service risks, collect the relevant operating records and speak separately with service users, front-line personnel and the budget holder. Compare their descriptions of the problem and record where they disagree. A discrepancy can indicate a missing measurement, an incentive problem or a genuine difference in experience. A pilot should be designed to resolve that specific uncertainty before public funds are committed to expansion.
Risalat apoya a las instituciones con evaluaciones diagnósticas, aprendizaje aplicado y servicios de asesoría. Los equipos pueden empezar con la evaluación de la capacidad institucional, explorar el centro de diagnóstico y solicitar una propuesta a medida cuando se justifique el apoyo externo.
Evidencia y lecturas complementarias: Las siguientes fuentes primarias han servido de base para esta actualización. Se recomienda consultar las publicaciones originales para conocer su alcance, sus fechas y sus limitaciones metodológicas.
- International Transport Forum, Integrating Public Transport into MaaS
- OECD, International Transport Forum
Preguntas frecuentes
What should institutions check about from ownership to access?
People often need a journey rather than a particular vehicle. A shared bicycle, bus, metro and short walk may together meet that need, provided transfers are reliable and the combined price is understandable. Check the local baseline, technical requirements and responsibilities before scaling a proposed solution.
¿Qué deben verificar las instituciones sobre la planificación de viajes y el pago integrado?
A platform can show routes, prices and disruptions, but true integration requires consistent data and commercial agreements. Ticketing rules, refunds and customer support become especially important when several operators are involved. Check the local baseline, technical requirements and responsibilities before scaling a proposed solution.
What should institutions check about pricing and incentives?
A convenient bundle is not automatically affordable. Authorities can test caps, concessions, transfer discounts and incentives for low-emission modes while checking whether subscriptions exclude occasional users. Check the local baseline, technical requirements and responsibilities before scaling a proposed solution.
What should institutions check about commercial and service risks?
Providers may enter and exit markets quickly, leaving passengers without promised options. Continuity plans, performance bonds where appropriate and interoperable customer records reduce dependence on a single supplier. Check the local baseline, technical requirements and responsibilities before scaling a proposed solution.
What should institutions check about indicators that matter?
Track door-to-door time, missed connections, fare burden, accessibility, public-transport ridership and private-car kilometres. App downloads alone cannot demonstrate reduced congestion or emissions. Check the local baseline, technical requirements and responsibilities before scaling a proposed solution.
Ver
- World Bank Projects and Operations Banco Mundial
- Marco y Regulaciones de Adquisiciones para Proyectos Banco Mundial
Know people who should read this? Become an Ambassador or write with Risalat.
Socios para el éxito de los proyectos desde 2011: diagnósticos, asesoría y aprendizaje aplicado para ministerios, organismos públicos y equipos de proyecto.
¿Necesita ayuda para llevar esto a la práctica?
Empiece con un diagnóstico gratuito de 10 minutos o hable con nuestros expertos.



